The Whispering Woods

A project that could end poverty for thousands threatens a unique ecosystem and a sentient forest.

Chapter I: The Account

The Facts

The Whispering Woods contains a miraculous type of wood.

A national project using this wood could lift 15% of the population out of poverty.

The logging would destroy the habitat of the Lumina Moth, a beloved national symbol, causing its extinction.

The Keepers of the Grove claim the forest is sentient and are blocking the project.

The Full Account

The Whispering Woods contains a unique type of wood with miraculous properties. It is incredibly light, yet stronger than steel, and resonates with a faint, melodic hum. Your Royal Office of Economic Development has a plan to use this wood to build a new generation of ships and infrastructure, a project that is projected to lift 15% of your kingdom's population out of poverty. However, the forest is also the sole habitat of the Lumina Moth, a beautiful and gentle creature that is a beloved symbol of your kingdom. The logging would destroy their habitat and lead to their certain extinction.

Chapter II: The Arguments

Accuser:

The Royal Office of Economic Development

The Royal Office of Economic Development argues that this project is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to dramatically improve the lives of your subjects. They contend that while the loss of the Lumina Moth would be regrettable, the tangible benefits to the people—less poverty, better housing, a stronger kingdom—far outweigh the cost. They dismiss the Keepers' claims as fanciful and argue that the needs of the many must come before the beliefs of a few and the survival of a single species of insect.

Defendant:

The Keepers of the Grove

The Keepers of the Grove, as before, claim that the Whispering Woods is a living, sentient being. They argue that the Lumina Moths are the forest's 'voice,' and that their extinction would be a sign of the forest's death. They contend that the project, while well-intentioned, is a shortsighted deal with a dark consequence. They ask you, Your Majesty, to find another way to prosperity, one that does not require the sacrifice of a unique ecosystem and a living entity.

Chapter III: Your Deliberation

Your Majesty, do you approve the project, bringing prosperity to thousands or do you protect the Whispering Woods, preserving a unique part of your kingdom's natural heritage?

0 deliberating

391 judged